Conisbrough Station Road did not reach a Totty Cup or Clarke Shield final. No doubt they were involved in other finals.

Years where we have a photo, but the team didn’t reach a final…
1958:  No finals Photo https://tottycup.wordpress.com/1950s/1958-2/ (scroll down)
1968: No finals Photo https://tottycup.wordpress.com/1960s/1968-2/ (scroll down)