This is an evolving list of players that have won the Totty Cup twice. Further down the page, we will also include players who played in two finals (Totty Cup, Barlow-Salmons etc).
George Saunders – Swinton Queen – 2022 & 2023
Harry Clark – Swinton Queen – 2022 & 2023
Matty Beckitt – Swinton Queen – 2022 & 2023
Reuben Hollings – Swinton Queen – 2022 & 2023
Charlie Branagan – Swinton Queen – 2022 & 2023
Harry Atkinson* – Swinton Queen – 2022 & 2023
*Harry wasn’t part of the 2022 final squad but he covered an illness in an earlier round.
Rex Lee – Bolton Carrfield – 2017 & 2018
James Law – Bolton Carrfield – 2017 & 2018
James Tindle – Bolton Carrfield – 2017 & 2018
Reece Denman – Bolton Carrfield – 2017 & 2018
Henry Jones – Bolton Carrfield – 2017 & 2018
Rio Ansu-Gyeabour – Bolton Carrfield – 2017 & 2018
Kaden Elliot – Bolton Carrfield – 2017 & 2018
Mason Wright – Bolton Carrfield – 2017 & 2018
Chris Sambrook – Thurnscoe Hill – 1996 & 1997
Daniel Birchall – Thurnscoe Hill – 1996 & 1997
Steven Marshall – Thurnscoe Hill – 1996 & 1997
Ian Hudson – Thurnscoe Hill – 1981 & 1982
Paul Thompson – Thurnscoe Hill – 1981 & 1982
Alan Richardson – Wath Central – 1974* & 1975
Nigel Armitage – Wath Central – 1974* & 1975
Alistair Fisher – Wath Central – 1974* & 1975
Barry Love – Wath Central – 1974* & 1975
*shared
Gary Banham – Thurnscoe Hill – 1968 & 1969
Gary Kerley – Thurnscoe Hill – 1968 & 1969
Chris Goddard – Schofield Street – 1963* & 1964
Martin Waggitt – Schofield Street – 1963* & 1964
Terry Fuller – Schofield Street – 1963* & 1964
Rob Davison – Schofield Street – 1963* & 1964
Steve Chadwick – Schofield Street – 1963* & 1964
Cliff Pearson – Schofield Street – 1963* & 1964
Gordon Goodall – Highgate – 1956 & 1957
John Hillson – Highgate – 1956 & 1957
Terry Parker – Highgate – 1956 & 1957
Colin Claxton – Highgate – 1956 & 1957
Tommy Randerson – Highgate – 1956 & 1957
George Robledo – Brampton Ellis – 1939 & 1940Eric Gardner – Schofield Street – 1963* & 1964
Thought Eric may have won it twice, bit now understand that 1964 would have been his brother Geoff Gardner
Look up these
1997 & 1996 – Hill – may be more
1955 & 1954 – Darfield Council
1947-1951 – Darfield Council
1939 & 1940 – Brampton Ellis
1936 & 1937 & 1938 – Bolton
1927* & 1928 – Brampton
Double Winners – Totty Cup & Barlow-Salmons
Totty Cup 1995 & Barlow-Salmons 1996 : Wath Central – Mark Ashburn, Adam Ball, Joel Nicholson, Danny Lunn and Jamie Cocking (Ball, Lunn and Cocking netting in the 96 final.)
Double winner of the Barlow-Salmons in 1978 & the Totty Cup in 1979 – Paul Cheetham, Phil Green, Darren Foster, and Adrian Smelt
Double winners with Carrfield for Andy Mangham and Darren Scothern who won the Barlow-Salmons in 1977 and the Totty Cup in 1978
Carrfield’s Alex Steadman and Phil Taylor won the Barlow-Salmons in 1992 & the Totty Cup in 1994. Presumably they played in the 1993 Totty Cup final too? Three finals is a rare achievement.
Swinton Queen
Josh Hill, (2014, Totty, 2013 Barlow)
Sam Winstanley, (2014, Totty, 2013 Barlow)
Michael Yu, (2014, Totty, 2013 Barlow)
Aaron Cocking, (2014, Totty, 2013 Barlow)
Nathan Walsh (2013 Barlow, 2012 Totty) – Nathan scored 1 in the 2012 Totty Cup win and then FIVE in the 2013 Barlow-Salmons final.
Double Clarke
Peter Gill won the Clarke Shield in 1963 & 1964 playing for Wath Central.
Two Finals
Harley Norris 2015 & 2016 Harley won the Totty cup in 2015 scoring in every round including 2 in the final. Unfortunately lost in the final the following year, but still notched a brace in the final.
Shaun Daykin played for Thurnscoe Hill in the Totty Cup final 1979 and the Barlow-Salmons final in 1980
Stephen Bramham has two Don & Dearne medals having been an unused substitute for Rawmarsh Sandhill in 1975 and then won the Totty Cup in 1977.
Tyler Pugh played in the 2015 and 2016 Totty Cup finals with Lacewood Primary School. He was the goal keeper for the 2015 final and not sure what position he played in the 2016
Ashton Powney played in the 2018 and 2019 Totty Cup finals for Lacewood.
Brookfield Barlow-Salmons finals in 2003 & 2004 for all these players: Josh Wilcock, Brett Cooke, Adam Callis, Ryan Ardron, Jordan Scivens
John Powney played for Carrfield in 1993 & 1994 Totty Cup finals.
Mark McDonnell played for Highgate in the Barlow-Salmons finals of 1979 and 1980.
Lee Baker played in the 1980 Barlow Salmons final and the 1981 Totty Cup final for Thurnscoe Hill.
John Powney played for Carrfield in 1993 & 1994 Totty Cup finals.
Andy Ashley played for Carrfield in the 1993 Totty Cup defeat, then in the Totty Cup win in 1994,
Steve McDonnell, Paul Howard, Chris Chapman, Chris Kane, Jonathan Norris & Andrew Smith played for Highgate in the Barlow-Salmons finals of 1979 and 1980.
Mike Fox played in the Totty Cup finals of 1972 and 1974 for Wath Central.
Kevin Lester was one of 4 Brampton Ellis players who played in both the 2000 and the 2001 Totty Cup finals. The other 3 were Kurtis Senior , Chris Burns and Robert Lazenby.
Player & Coach Double
Alex Steadman won the Totty Cup in 1994 with Carrfield as a player.
Alex then returned to Carrfield as a teacher before leading Thurnscoe Hill to the Totty Cup final in 2011.